Peter Jackson in Talks to Film The Silmarillion — Everything We Know

This is the most significant piece of Tolkien news since the original Lord of the Rings trilogy was announced. Not because a deal exists, but because the conversation is happening at all, in public, confirmed by Jackson himself. The Silmarillion has been the locked room of Tolkien's legendarium for fifty years. Yesterday, for the first time, someone with the relationships and the intention to open it told a room full of journalists that the key is being cut.

What Jackson Actually Said — The Exact Quotes

Jackson's comments were made in a wide-ranging masterclass at Cannes the morning after his Honorary Palme d'Or ceremony. He was not asked directly about The Silmarillion. The subject came up in the context of discussing the future of the franchise, and he went further than anyone had expected.

"Christopher Tolkien sort of edited and finished other Tolkien books, The Silmarillion, Unfinished Tales, there's a lot more Tolkien writing which would actually make great movies, that were subsequently edited and released by Christopher. But he just absolutely not... those rights have never been available."

He then added: "But Christopher passed away recently, well, I suppose two or three years ago now, and the younger Tolkiens, this next generation, are now running the estate. They're much more open to talking. So a combination of Warners and us have been talking to the younger members about the possibility of actually licensing the rights to some of the other books. It would be nice to get away from the appendices and get something a bit more meaty."

Three things in that statement are worth holding separately. First: Warner Bros. is involved, not just Jackson personally. This is not a filmmaker's aspiration. It is an active studio negotiation. Second: Jackson used the word "meaty." The appendices have given us the original trilogy, The Hobbit, The War of the Rohirrim, The Rings of Power, The Hunt for Gollum, and Shadow of the Past. Everything that has been filmed in the Jackson era has come from Tolkien's main texts or his appendices. The Silmarillion is not an appendix. It is the complete mythology of the Elder Days: the creation of the world, the Wars of Beleriand, Beren and Lúthien, the Fall of Gondolin, the story of Eärendil whose star Sam sees from the slopes of Mordor. It is where everything in The Lord of the Rings comes from. Third: "those rights have never been available" means that every previous conversation about a Silmarillion film was theoretical. This one is apparently not.

Why The Silmarillion Has Never Been Filmed — Until Now

When Tolkien sold the film rights to The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit in the 1960s, he specifically excluded his other works. The Silmarillion, which he was still writing and which he never completed in his lifetime, remained with his estate. When he died in 1973, the estate passed to his son Christopher Tolkien, who spent the next forty-seven years editing and publishing his father's unfinished manuscripts: The Silmarillion (1977), Unfinished Tales (1980), The History of Middle-earth (twelve volumes, 1983-1996), The Children of Húrin (2007), Beren and Lúthien (2017), and The Fall of Gondolin (2018).

Christopher Tolkien was deeply opposed to further film adaptations. He was not simply protective of his father's work in the abstract sense. He actively and publicly criticised the Peter Jackson films, describing them as transforming his father's work into "action films for young people" that had "eviscerated the book by making it an action movie for 15 to 25 year olds." He would not grant further film rights under any circumstances. The Silmarillion was never available, in the same way that a door is never available when someone has decided it will not open.

Christopher Tolkien died on January 16, 2020, aged 95. The estate passed to a new generation of Tolkien family members. Jackson's comment that they are "much more open to talking" is the first public confirmation that the change in stewardship has changed the availability of the rights. Amazon's Rings of Power series demonstrated the commercial scale of Tolkien adaptation in the streaming era. The Hunt for Gollum demonstrated that Jackson and Warner Bros. were actively rebuilding the franchise. Those two facts together created the conditions for a conversation that could not have happened five years ago.

What The Silmarillion Actually Is

For readers who know Tolkien only through The Lord of the Rings or the films, The Silmarillion requires some context, because it is not a novel in the conventional sense. It is a mythology: the creation story, the early history, and the great tales of the First Age of Middle-earth, written in a style that draws on the Old Norse Eddas and the Finnish Kalevala rather than on the narrative tradition of the novel.

Within it are stories of an ambition and emotional scale that The Lord of the Rings can only gesture toward. The tale of Beren and Lúthien, a mortal man and an immortal Elvish princess who together descend into the fortress of the first Dark Lord Morgoth to steal a jewel from his crown, is the love story that Tolkien considered the heart of his entire legendarium. He wrote it first, in the trenches of the First World War. His wife Edith danced for him in a forest clearing and became Lúthien. Their names are on their shared gravestone at Wolvercote Cemetery in Oxford. It is the story behind the story.

The Fall of Gondolin is the founding disaster of the First Age: the destruction of the most beautiful Elvish city ever built, betrayed from within, burned by dragons and Balrogs in a single night, with a small group of survivors escaping through a hidden pass in the mountains. The survivors included Tuor, who would father Eärendil, who would father Elrond and Elros. Everything that follows in The Lord of the Rings flows from that night.

The Children of Húrin is the darkest thing Tolkien ever wrote: a tragedy of Shakespearean proportions, following Túrin Turambar through a life shaped by a curse laid on his family by Morgoth, ending in incest, madness, and a sword that speaks its name before it kills. It has nothing of the consolatory resolution that The Lord of the Rings offers. It ends as Greek tragedy ends: completely, without comfort.

These are not supplementary materials. They are the foundational texts of an entire mythology. They are what The Lord of the Rings is the coda to. The idea of them on screen is staggering.

What Would a Silmarillion Film Actually Look Like?

This is the question that immediately follows any news about The Silmarillion rights, and it is genuinely difficult to answer. The Silmarillion as published is not a single narrative. It is a collection of connected myths, genealogies, and histories spanning thousands of years and dozens of major characters. Adapting it as written would produce something like a Norse mythology compendium: magnificent but unfilmable as a single piece.

The practical approach would be to adapt individual stories from within it as standalone films: Beren and Lúthien as one film, The Fall of Gondolin as another, The Children of Húrin as a third. Each is a complete narrative with a beginning, middle, and end. Each is the scale of a major epic film. Each is set in a world that the production teams who built Middle-earth for six existing Jackson films know intimately, at least in its geography and aesthetic.

Jackson's comment that he wants "something meatier" than the appendices points in this direction. He is not describing a documentary adaptation of the full text. He is describing stories with genuine narrative weight: characters, arcs, stakes, tragedy. Beren and Lúthien has all of these. The Fall of Gondolin has all of these. The Children of Húrin has all of these and then some.

The rights question is also more complicated than a single negotiation. The Silmarillion's rights belong to the Tolkien Estate. The Lord of the Rings film rights belong to Warner Bros. through the original sale. Amazon's Rings of Power has some rights to the Second Age material from the appendices. Multiple parties would need to be aligned for any First Age adaptation to move forward cleanly. Jackson acknowledged this complexity is part of why the talks are at an early stage.

What This Means for the World of Tolkien on Screen

Jackson said one more thing at Cannes that has not been widely reported: he is also writing a new Tintin script with Fran Walsh, and still hopes to make a film about the Dambusters Raid. He is not a man who has nothing to do. His willingness to describe The Silmarillion talks publicly at all suggests he considers them serious enough to be worth naming, which is itself a signal.

For the world of Middle-earth on screen, the implications are enormous if the talks succeed. The existing films are all set in the Third Age, with brief excursions into the Second Age through the Rings of Power series. The First Age has never been touched. It contains the most dramatic events in the entire history of Tolkien's world: the original wars against Morgoth, the destruction of the Two Trees that lit Valinor, the creation of the Silmarils, three wars of escalating catastrophe, the drowning of Beleriand at the end of it all. It is the deep history that every event in The Lord of the Rings refers back to.

Galadriel watched the Two Trees die. Elrond's father Eärendil sailed across the sea to beg the Valar for help in the final war. The star Sam sees from Mordor is Eärendil wearing a Silmaril. When Aragorn calls himself "Estel," Hope, it is because he carries the bloodline of the survivors of the greatest catastrophes of the First Age. All of it is connected. The Silmarillion is where those connections live.

We do not yet know if the rights deal will be made. We know the conversation is happening. For a body of work that has been locked behind a closed door for fifty years, that is extraordinary news.

The Official Collection — Made in New Zealand

Every piece of officially licensed Lord of the Rings jewellery at lotrjewelry.com comes from the world The Silmarillion underlies: the One Ring Sauron forged using the craft the Elves learned in the First Age, the Evenstar pendant connecting Aragorn to the bloodline of Beren and Lúthien, Nenya the Ring of Water whose connection to the First Age runs through Galadriel herself. Made in New Zealand by the New Line Productions licence holders, in the country where Middle-earth has lived on screen for twenty-five years.

Frequently Asked Questions